Free Speech

Why Kathleen Stock’s treatment is a modern day witch hunt that should worry everyone

Universities that should be havens of free speech are being turned into bastions of conformity: repeat the mantra or face the consequences.

Are we reversing out of the scientific enlightenment? The frenzied scenes from Sussex University this week suggest that we might be. This should worry everyone. When a professor of philosophy is hounded by a mob for supposedly having the wrong opinions, the age of reason is in danger.

We’re told that Professor Kathleen Stock is a ‘Terf’. That acronym has been well and truly detached from trans-exclusionary radical feminist. It can now be smeared onto any woman with the audacity to cling on to her sex-based rights. Rights we once took for granted are now vulnerable: single-sex spaces and facilities, and the right to form single-sex groups and associations. Even the word, woman, is being wrestled from the sex it once described.

The penalties are severe – reputations and livelihoods are at stake – and the impact cuts to the core. The bullying and intimidation is enough to devastate anyone’s mental health.

Stock is certainly not the first woman to be condemned for Terf-craft, but the sheer scale of the vitriol she has faced has generated widespread attention. Much support has come from fellow academics and others. Over two thousand have signed one statement alone. They are right to support her, she has done nothing wrong.

But as in the days of the witch hunts, rights and wrongs are less important than feelings and emotions. The mob is angry because it’s offended by people who think differently. The means are justified by the ends, and in this case we’re told that the ends are trans rights.

The mantras are tedious and repetitive: Trans rights are human rights; transwomen are women; and the rest. The first is self-evident – trans people are human – while the second is just not true.

I am transgender and I have been through a full medical and surgical transition, but I’m still just as male as I was the day I was born. Hormone therapy can develop secondary sex characteristics and gender surgery can remodel the genitals themselves, but human beings cannot change sex. We all know this, really, but too many people are scared to admit it. That is perhaps understandable: who wants to be the next Kathleen Stock?

Universities that should be havens of free speech are being turned into bastions of conformity: repeat the mantra or face the consequences.

Over at Cambridge University, the Student Union Women’s Campaign is on a mission to dismantle the sex-based rights their mothers, grandmothers and great grandmothers won for them. Boldly, they announce, ‘Your gender is never questioned at WomCam events – we assume that if you are here, that this space is meant for you!’ Their naivety is breathtaking.

But they refuse to listen to older women who do understand the need for boundaries and safeguards. Their 2021-22 campaign booklet, How to Spot Terf Ideology, takes foolishness to a new level. The message is, stay in your bubble. When it comes to ‘Talking to Terfs online’, the booklet suggests, ‘The key advice is don’t.’

When Cambridge Students are told to stay in their echo chambers we should all worry. Admittedly the diktat has come from a Student Union campaign – but a sinister message seems to be creeping through society. Terfs are to be identified, marginalised, smeared and hounded from their jobs. Just because they appreciate the importance of sex in human relationships and human society. 

We cannot leave a few brave souls like Kathleen Stock, Rosie Duffield and JK Rowling to stand against this tirade, and defend the rights of women. Political leaders need to start giving straight answers to straight questions: women are adult human females and only women have a cervix. But we cannot wait for them. The responsibility falls on everyone to step up and defend not only women’s rights, but the enlightenment that made them possible. Silence is not an option.

Debbie Hayton

Debbie Hayton is a transgender British secondary school science teacher and political activist.

* This article was first published by Mail+ on 15 October 2021: Why Kathleen Stock’s treatment is a modern day witch hunt that should worry everyone.

6 replies on “Why Kathleen Stock’s treatment is a modern day witch hunt that should worry everyone”

What do we do though Debbie? How do we support this important message without being a victim of the pitchfork mob? Or do you believe it’s a necessary part of the fight to expose yourself to that risk? I Read with great interest an article you wrote in August referring to the 3 groups this ideology makes vulnerable: women, children and transsexuals. The most worrying thing about your observation is the vast majority just don’t see it. That’s a compelling reason for taking the risk, it’s just very daunting when it could result in job loss/ social isolation.
Love your work.

Liked by 2 people

I take it that you’re a young woman who finds that you may be in a precarious position at work or with family and friends if you express gender critical beliefs? What each of us can do is personal according to our situation. No one doubts that speaking out for some women can be fraught with risk. Some adopt an alternative identity so they can engage online or write blogs or journals, just like some authors of books used pseudonyms sometimes, for whatever reason they had at the time. You may be able to join a group, and if not able to be active within it, you may be able to make a small financial contribution either regularly, or just when you can. These are difficult times to be a woman who won’t conform to the current popular narrative, and I understand the frustration at feeling you can’t openly express your stance, but wanting to. When I was a young woman, I had no such restrictions, so to have gone backwards like this is appalling. Even then we still had women who participated in their own oppression, but nothing like current times. I find that Legal Feminist, who are a GC organisation, often has good advice for us. Here’s one article about what we can do if we’re asked to announce pronouns in the workplace which might have useful information in it for you.

Liked by 2 people

Thank you Katrina, I’m not that young actually, but work in the academic field, so you see my problem.
The pseudonym is a good idea and one I’ll consider. I have taken myself off main social media recently after finally reading Jaron Lanier’s book, so needs some thought how best to do this.

Liked by 2 people

Yes, academia is one of the worst places to be right now if you have GC views. If you choose a pseudonym, choose a man’s name, or at least one that can be either/or. You’ll he surprised at the feeling of freedom a man’s name gives you 😄

Liked by 1 person

Thankyou Debbie for speaking up for women. You word everything really well, truthfully and are very brave. I honestly think the majority of people don’t know of the incidents happening here and around the world, injustices such as-many stories of male rapists attack women in female prisons, women/people cancelled, student set on by 20 students, child taken from parents-transitioned by state-out of state care at 18yrs-wished hadn’t transitioned-felt had no-one, committed suicide (utter tragedy). I only noticed because my daughter told me she knew lesbians threatened by tw they’d report them as transphobes to their unis and jobs if they didn’t sleep with them. But she recently said trans people she knows aren’t like these news stories, just want to get on with their lives, give people a wide berth. My daughter doesn’t know about or believe these incidents she immediately calls everyone a transphobe so I’m very worried about her. Mainstream media TV don’t report these incidents so, I think Brits tolerate everything around them which they disagree inside with, until it effects them directly.

Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s